Poisonal
World
Poisonal
The Castro (Formerly Theatre)

Bathhouse Approved Where Historic District Won't Fit It

San Francisco Planning Commission members at a dais in city hall studying two framed architectural elevations side by side, one all glass storefront and one fully opaque, one commissioner holding a ruler against the glass one, a stenographer typing.AI illustration

— San Francisco's Planning Commission approved the city's first gay bathhouse in decades after a variance on transparency. Twin Peaks Tavern, Landmark No. 264, is legally required to keep its windows open and unobscured.

The San Francisco Planning Commission voted 7-0 to approve Sanctum Baths, the first bathhouse permitted under the city's 2022 rules, and in the same motion formally confirmed that the neighborhood's obligation to be seen has been assigned to a single bar on Castro Street.

Under the variance, the bathhouse is excused from the planning code's ground-floor transparency standard. Under Landmark No. 264, Twin Peaks Tavern is not. Staff described the arrangement as balanced, noting that one building would now be see-through on behalf of both.

Interview Transcript
Excerpt: Variance Hearing
San Francisco Planning Commission, Regular Hearing
COMMISSIONER HALVORSEN:
Is there precedent for exempting a business from transparency?
STAFF PLANNER DENISE OKAFOR:
There is precedent for the opposite. Twin Peaks Tavern, opened 1935, is credited as the first gay bar with full-length clear plate-glass windows.
COMMISSIONER HALVORSEN:
So the city has one building that must be looked into.
STAFF PLANNER DENISE OKAFOR:
Yes. The landmark designation requires the glass stay open and unobscured. We consider that the neighborhood's allotment.
COMMISSIONER PRUITT:
[pause] Could the tavern apply for the same variance?
STAFF PLANNER DENISE OKAFOR:
It would have to stop being historic first.
COMMISSIONER PRUITT:
Then it's the glass coffin by statute.
STAFF PLANNER DENISE OKAFOR:
We don't use that term. The regulars do. We just enforce it.

The ruling was read into the record without objection. Planning staff later clarified that any regular who wishes to drink unobserved may do so at Sanctum, which will serve no drinks.

"We fought for those windows in 1972 so nobody had to hide," said Walt Brenner, 74, who has had the same stool by the glass since the Twin Peaks Tavern reopened that year. "Now I'm the only one who isn't allowed to."

The commission said the tavern's legal duty to be visible would be reviewed if anyone ever complained about being seen.

⚖️ Versus

Transparency Obligations, As Approved

🪟

Twin Peaks Tavern

👀WindowsMust stay open and unobscured
📜Legal statusLandmark No. 264
Winner 🏆
🧖

Sanctum Baths

🚫Windows🏆 Variance granted
✅Legal statusApproved 7-0

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature
🪟 Twin Peaks Tavern
🧖 Sanctum Baths
WindowsMust stay open and unobscuredVariance granted
Legal statusLandmark No. 264🏆 Approved 7-0

Bottom Line

Staff noted the landmark designation cannot be transferred, only inherited.

The bathhouse expects to open late next year. The tavern's windows were cleaned twice during the hearing. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

Why are Twin Peaks Tavern's windows legally protected in San Francisco?Get the straight answer →

More from The Castro

The Castro front page
The Castro
D8 & Escrow
Castro Listing Calls Neighborhood 'Historically Gay,' Like Gettysburg

A Eureka Valley listing offers the Castro's 'historic LGBTQ heritage' as an amenity, with the median home at $1.35 million. Buyers are told the heritage conveys with the property, but the original residents do not.

Related: From 500,000 on the street to a night market with a permit: the de-wilding of the Castro
The Castro
The Flag Desk
SFMTA Wins Castro Halloween Costume Contest as a Detour

Judges cited SFMTA's full commitment: 18th Street closed from 11 a.m., the 33 Ashbury/18th rerouted, and a map. Runner-up was a private security vendor dressed as a private security vendor.

Related: From 500,000 on the street to a night market with a permit: the de-wilding of the Castro
The Castro
The Flag Desk
Castro Merchants Drop Two More Stripes to Save on Fabric

To save on $1,200 replacements, the Harvey Milk Plaza flag loses two more stripes, as hot pink did when fabric ran short. Each surviving stripe will be sold to a corporate sponsor for Pride Month, then returned in July.

Nearby in Castro
The Castro
Milk Plaza, Eventually
Gay History Museum Will Open When the Gym Lease Ends in 2040, Outliving Its Docents

The GLBT Historical Society museum will open in the $11.6 million Market & Noe Center when the gym downstairs leaves in 2040. Until then, the history will be taught downstairs in 50-minute intervals with a cooldown.

Nearby in Castro
The Castro
Four Stories Max
City Approves Final Rebuilding Permit From 1906 Fire

The Department of Building Inspection approved the last rebuilding permit from the 1906 earthquake and fire, which destroyed most of San Francisco. Staff called the 120-year review expedited and told the applicant's great-grandchildren that neighbors may still appeal.

Nearby in San Francisco
The Castro
For Lease on Castro
Castro Landlords Fund Campaign to Keep Harvey Milk Plaza Unbuilt Forever

Castro landlords, exempt from the vacancy tax near long-term public projects, are funding a committee to keep Harvey Milk Plaza pending forever. Its first mailer calls a 2027 groundbreaking rushed, and praises Harvey Milk's famous patience.

Nearby in Castro
The CastroSan Francisco

The flag gets replaced every three months. The storefronts, less often.

The Castro front page
Satire

The The Castro paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting and filed on an 18th Street permit. Everyone quoted is made up, no real official is quoted, and the vacancy count is the Merchants' own.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.