Pluto Marks 20 Years Since Being Fired Before Its First Annual Review
AI illustration
World — Pluto was a planet for 76 years, under a third of one orbit, before 424 astronomers voted it out in Prague. The International Astronomical Union had about 10,000 members, so whoever stayed for the last day did the firing.
Pluto's personnel file, reviewed this week by an outside human-resources consultant retained by the Office of the Final Communiqué, contains no prior warnings, no coaching notes and no documented concerns in 76 years of continuous service. "The file is clean," the consultant said. "It is so clean it is suspicious. Either nothing was ever wrong, or nobody was ever looking." The consultant declined to say which explanation the committee preferred, noting that the committee had not, at any point, been asked.
The file also shows that the position description, "clears its orbit," was added to the official role criteria during the same week the termination was voted. Previous descriptions for the role did not mention orbit, neighbourhood or clearance. The consultant described the revision as "the kind of thing you do the week before the meeting, when you already know who is in the building on Friday."
The criteria were written after the verdict, and the quorum was whoever had not yet flown home.
Interview Transcript
Final Session, Prague, Thursday Afternoon
Recovered from the chair's working notes | Aug 24 2006
CHAIR:
[shuffling papers]We have a motion. Pluto, as a planet, does not meet the new definition. All those in favour, raise your yellow card.
CHAIR:
[checking watch]Counting. Four hundred and twenty-four. Thank you. I note that the membership is largely present, and most of them appear to have a flight this evening.
CHAIR:
[gavel, lightly]Let the record show that this is consensus.
Consistently spherical, to the satisfaction of every reviewer who looked.
Orbits the Sun
A
Dependable. Has never once left the solar system.
Clears Its Neighbourhood
F
Introduced as a criterion in the final week. No earlier warning given.
Years of Service
76
Discovered by Clyde Tombaugh, who was not asked for an opinion.
Laps Completed
0.3
Of 248. Not for want of trying.
“Not a bad planet. Just not the right planet for the room.”
The New Horizons spacecraft reached Pluto on July 14 2015, nine years after the committee's vote, and transmitted the first close images of the dwarf planet's surface. Agency officials described the flyby as a scientific triumph. Pluto did not comment, having been without standing to do so since the vote.
"It's like a manager showing up to the exit interview with a box of cookies," said a source familiar with the consultant's file who asked not to be named. "Very kind. Very late. Nobody is quite sure what it's for."
The consultant advised that Pluto could not pursue any legal remedy. The dwarf planet is 3.7 billion miles from the nearest courtroom and has, in the consultant's words, "no atmosphere to speak of." Its case, if it had one, was filed in a building nobody can find on a map.
Retrospective Reclassification, 2026
4 OPTIONS · FILL ONE
FILL ONE OVAL, THEN CAST
What is Pluto now?
clear the neighbourhood
Definition
What you must have done to keep a title you were given before the rule existed.
The thing most people miss
The rule arrived after the job, and nobody was asked to meet it in advance.
Pluto completes one orbit of the sun every 248 years. It has not completed one since it was discovered in 1930, and will not complete its first full lap since then until 2178. The International Astronomical Union has not commented on the anniversary.Pluto takes 248 years to orbit the sun once. It has not finished one since it was discovered. ■
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.