Wine Trade Declares Asian Market 'Crumbs' Now Worth Fighting Over
Bordeaux — Producers have voted to treat remaining Chinese and Hong Kong orders as a cherished harvest, and the sector has pledged to protect each crumb with a dedicated export committee. Officials confirmed the committee will meet in Hong Kong, where the crumbs are kept.
- To:
- All Committee Members
- From:
- Hélène Marchand, Secretary, Crumb Custody
- Date:
- November 14, 2025
- Re:
- Minutes, Inaugural Session (Hong Kong)
The committee convened in the Hong Kong hotel lobby, the meeting room having been booked by a larger crumb from Burgundy.
- •A Hong Kong order shall be called a crumb.
- •A mainland China order shall be called a former loaf.
- •A cancelled order shall be called a crumb in transit.
- •Crumb 1: six cases, Saint-Émilion, confirmed.
- •Crumb 2: three cases, paid in instalments, cherished.
- •Crumb 3: one case, buyer has stopped answering, retained for morale.
Committee Guidance for Producers
But seriously…
The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.
Why did Bordeaux wine sales to China and Hong Kong collapse?Get the straight answer →




