Poisonal
World
Poisonal
The Big Build

Sunbury Crossing Cost $6M More Because Everyone Was Paid to Be Late

AI illustration

— A 2022 CFMEU stoppage lifted the Sunbury level crossing target from $110 million to $116 million. The alliance delivered it for $104 million and kept 35 per cent of savings.

Spring Street welcomed the evidence Tuesday, saying the June 2022 CFMEU stoppage had produced the first Big Build project in a decade to come in under budget, provided the budget was the one written after the stoppage.

The Department of Transport and Planning has since nominated the Sunbury Gap Road crossing for an internal efficiency award, citing a $12 million saving against a target that existed for the purpose.

"Under this model the builder and the state want exactly the same thing," said Karen Doyle, the department's Director of Commercial Partnerships. "We just want it at different prices."

Memo
RNA
Rail Network Alliance
Keeping Victorians moving
To:
Sunbury Project Team
From:
Greg Mullins, Commercial Manager
Date:
July 4, 2022
Re:
Revised target cost following site pause

Following last month's pause, the state has agreed to lift the target cost from $110 million to $116 million. Please note the following language for all external correspondence.

Terminology:
  • •Stoppage is now schedule realignment.
  • •Delay is now target headroom.
  • •Overrun is now savings.
Next steps:
  • •Deliver for $104 million as planned.
  • •Book the 35 per cent savings share in the usual way.
  • •Do not schedule the next pause until the target is reset.
Thanks all,
Greg Mullins, Commercial Manager

The commission heard the higher target was worth about $2 million in extra profit to the alliance. The balance of the stoppage was absorbed by the state, which in Victoria is shorthand for anyone who pays land tax.

At the crossing, Sunbury commuter Leanne Hart said the boom gates had been replaced by a bridge she likes, at a price she was never shown. "I stood behind a sign that said Keeping Victorians moving for nine months," she said. "Nobody told me I was the investor."

Doyle confirmed the target-cost arrangement will be applied to the Suburban Rail Loop, where the department expects the longer build to generate proportionally larger pauses. Contractors on the Loop will be offered the same 35 per cent share of savings against whatever the target becomes.

The alliance said it had not been asked to give any money back and had not offered.The Big Build royal commission, led by Commissioner Christopher Kourakis on a $50 million budget, reports in August 2027. The department has offered it a 35 per cent share of anything it finishes early. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How does a target-cost alliance contract work, and why can a cost increase raise the builder's profit?Get the straight answer →

More from Melbourne

Melbourne front page
Melbourne
Spring Street
Liberals promise outer-suburban housing in two years.

The Liberal plan would fast-track 27 sites in two years, but Labor's 60 hubs near public transport won't have that transport until 2035. Polling shows 47 per cent of Greater Melbourne back the Liberal approach.

Related: The Suburban Rail Loop: 90km, $100 billion-plus, and the interchanges cut to save $2 billion
Melbourne
Spring Street
Glasgow Unveils Statue of the Victorian Taxpayer

Victoria funded about three-quarters of Glasgow's $303 million Commonwealth Games through a cancellation that cost it more than $589 million. The bronze, a man in a puffer reading his myki balance, cost $134,000, which Victoria had just stopped spending.

Nearby in Melbourne
Melbourne
Town Hall
Melbourne Council Candidates Begin Door-Knocking Car Parks

In City of Melbourne elections, businesses get two votes and must cast both, and city workers who live elsewhere get none. One Swanston Street car park has received more campaign flyers than cars.

Nearby in Melbourne
Melbourne
Opinion
I Can Live With $199 Billion in Debt, but Not a $5.66 Flat White

Victoria's net debt heads for $199.3 billion by 2030, about $32 million a day in interest, and I have said nothing. Then my Fitzroy cafe added 50 cents to my flat white, and I wrote to the ombudsman.

Nearby in Melbourne
Melbourne
Opinion
Inner-North Cafe Earns Restaurant Guide Listing Based Solely on Queue Length

A restaurant guide has listed an inner-north cafe for a queue its reviewer never got through, rating the wait as the product. The cafe's owner says the line is a reservation system and is considering charging for the spot in the line.

Nearby in Melbourne
Melbourne
Docklands & the Wheel
Melbourne Star Wheel Reopens, Operators Confirm Views Still Available From Inside

The Melbourne Star observation wheel in Docklands has reopened after an unspecified closure, with operators confirming the views remain available to any rider who has the patience to get on. The closure was the third this year, and the reopening is scheduled for review.

Nearby in Melbourne
MelbourneVictoria

Third most liveable city on earth, $199 billion in debt by 2030, and the airport train first legislated in 1965 is due in 2033.

Melbourne front page
Satire

The Melbourne paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real Victorian reporting. Nobody real is quoted saying anything they didn't say, the weather changed its mind twice while we wrote this, and the cost blowouts are the only thing we didn't need to exaggerate.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.