Poisonal
World
Poisonal
Opinion

A renter watches St Kilda's foreshore transform beyond recognition

— A longtime renter imagines owning St Kilda's transforming foreshore. He cannot afford to stay as property values soar.

I remember the kiosk. It sold a hot chip in a paper cone, and you ate it on the wall with your back to the Esplanade and your face to Port Phillip Bay, and nobody asked whether you had a booking. I was 24. I rented a room on Acland Street for $140 a week, and I thought that if I stayed long enough, the foreshore would one day be partly mine.

The foreshore is now experienced primarily as a menu. I have read it. The Stokehouse has reopened under Andrew McConnell, and Marea Beach House and Bar has opened down the road, and both come with a menu that I read in full on my phone while standing on the footpath, which is the only part of either I have been able to afford to occupy.

On Saturday I joined the queue for the Esplanade end of things. It moved at the speed of a person reading a wine list, which is the speed at which it was moving. A man ahead of me said he had waited 40 minutes to be told that the table was for a party of two and that he was a party of one. He said it without anger, the way you describe weather.

I have rented in this suburb for eleven years. In that time my landlord has changed three times and my rent has changed four. The sea has changed, as far as I can tell, not at all.

Quote

You're welcome to stand in the queue as long as you like. It's the only part of the foreshore that has never had a minimum spend.”

Graham Pettit, 61, resident of a one-bedroom unit above a Carlisle Street laundromat
Overheard at the queue, St Kilda foreshore

I went home. I did not have a table, a booking, or the confidence to ask for either. I made toast and ate it at the window, where the room's one advantage is a slice of bay between a neighbour's air conditioner and a billboard for a gym.

I looked at the sea for some time. It did not offer me a drinks list. It did not ask for a card. It did not tell me the kitchen closes at nine.The sea was free. 

But seriously…

The joke above is built on a real story. Here's the straight version.

How much has the rent in St Kilda risen over the past decade, and who is being priced out?Get the straight answer →

More from St Kilda

St Kilda front page
St Kilda
Stokehouse & Co.
Foreshore Restaurant Reopens Under Familiar Name, Residents Asked to Admire the Same View at Higher Prices

Stokehouse St Kilda has reopened under restaurateur Andrew McConnell, with a coastal menu of royal red prawn tart and whole butterflied King George whiting. Marea Beach House and Bar opened downstairs in October, and a summer pop-up is planned for the Kiosk. The view itself, as the menu makes clear, has not changed hands.

Related: Stokehouse St Kilda reopens under Andrew McConnell
St Kilda
The Pier
Penguins Decline Marea Beach House Opening Invitation

Little penguins at the St Kilda breakwater were reportedly sent invitations to the opening of Marea Beach House and Bar and did not reply. A spokesperson says the birds were never actually on the list.

Related: Marea Beach House and Bar opens in St Kilda
St Kilda
Stokehouse & Co.
Man Walks Past Stokehouse 11 Years, Asks for Table

Dennis Walsh, 61, of Acland Street, says he has watched three operators come and go and would like to see the inside before the fourth. He was handed a card with a phone number.

Related: Stokehouse St Kilda reopens under Andrew McConnell
St Kilda
The Pier
Hotel Esplanade Ghost Still Unbooked for Autumn, Reportedly Waiting for a Sponsor

Local lore holds that the ghost of merchant and philanthropist Alfred Felton haunts Hotel Esplanade, though the story is unverified. The ghost is reportedly seeking a sponsor for its autumn season, with no confirmed bookings.

Nearby in St Kilda
St Kilda
Spring Street
Glasgow Unveils Statue of the Victorian Taxpayer

Victoria funded about three-quarters of Glasgow's $303 million Commonwealth Games through a cancellation that cost it more than $589 million. The bronze, a man in a puffer reading his myki balance, cost $134,000, which Victoria had just stopped spending.

Nearby in Melbourne
St Kilda
Town Hall
Melbourne Council Candidates Begin Door-Knocking Car Parks

In City of Melbourne elections, businesses get two votes and must cast both, and city workers who live elsewhere get none. One Swanston Street car park has received more campaign flyers than cars.

Nearby in Melbourne
St KildaMelbourne

The beach is free. The view is on a menu, and the Esplanade is the wine list.

St Kilda front page
Satire

The St Kilda paper is satire from Poisonal News.

Satire, built on real local reporting. No quote is attributed to a real person.

It's written with AI from real local reporting. The facts link to their sources; everything else is invented. Every quote is made up, and the pictures are AI illustrations, not photographs.

Something here crosses a line? Report a problem

© 2026 AnyLearn, Inc.