Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Vintage Shop on Montmartre Hill Certifies Every Souvenir as 'Original,' Including Ones It Made Last Tuesday

A souvenir shop near the Sacre-Coeur has been selling items described as original and authentic for over a century, and the shopkeeper confirmed that the designation applies to goods of any age. Asked how the store determines originality, the shopkeeper said the door sign has said 'original' since 1924 and that this is evidence enough.

11 days ago • 8 min read

Shop Near Sacre-Coeur Stands by 'Original' Label on Goods Made This Week

MONTMARTRE — A souvenir shop on the slope below the Sacre-Coeur has labeled its merchandise original and authentic for more than a century, and the proprietor confirmed Thursday that the designation covers goods of any age, including items produced within the past seven days. Asked how the store determines originality, the shopkeeper, who declined to give a name and was reached through a shop bell that rang twice before anyone came to the counter, said the door sign has read original since 1924 and that this is evidence enough. The bell is original, the shopkeeper added. The postcards are original. The rack is original. If the rack is original, the postcards are original. Staff did not respond to questions about whether the rack had been checked. The shop's claim to originality rests on a sign, and no one has been asked to examine the goods.

A shopkeeper stands by a dusty postcard rack beside a freshly taped box labeled ORIGINAL on a counter in a souvenir shop.

Staff confirm the rack is original. The box was delivered Tuesday.

Quotation

If the rack is original, the postcards are original.”

Anonymous shopkeeper, Montmartre
Souvenir shop near the Sacre-Coeur, responding to questions about originality
The shopkeeper's logic runs entirely on inheritance: the object's status comes from the furniture around it, not from anything anyone has examined.

The Sign's Documented History

🪧1924
Door sign installed reading 'original'
The sign is the store's only recorded certification. It has not been reviewed since.
🔔1924–2019
Sign remains in place
Goods sold during this period were not individually assessed. The bell continued to ring.
📦Last Tuesday
New merchandise received
Cardboard boxes were delivered and unpacked. The sign was not moved.
✅Thursday
Shop reaffirms originality
Asked about the new stock, the proprietor said the sign covers it. Asked whether anyone had checked, the proprietor said the sign has been there since 1924.
Frequently Asked

Questions Put to the Shop

The store relies on the door sign, which has read original since 1924. Staff described this as sufficient. The store did not say who installed the sign or whether it has ever been re-evaluated against new stock.
Yes. The proprietor confirmed that the label applies to goods of any age, including products delivered within the past week.
The shopkeeper said the rack is original. When asked how this was determined, the shopkeeper said the rack was original enough, and that the postcards are original by association.
The shopkeeper said the sign is the claim and cannot be withdrawn without taking the sign down. The sign remains up.

Asked Whether the Sign Has Been Tested

The proprietor was asked, after the bell rang a third time, whether the 1924 sign had ever been measured against a shelf of new goods. The proprietor said the sign was original enough and that the question had been answered in 1924. The sign has never been checked. It hangs above the door, where anyone entering can read it before picking up a keychain shaped like the basilica, which was delivered last week and which the store is prepared to certify as a heritage item without further review.

More from Montmartre