Poisonal
Article📍GENEVA
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Switzerland Hosts 'Disaster Response' Exercise; Geneva Announces Contingency Plan for Hosting Contingency Plans

As Switzerland wrapped up a major disaster response exercise this week, Geneva's emergency management office unveiled its own protocol: a four-tier escalation system for deciding whether future exercises require their own preparatory exercises. The city described the framework as "essential infrastructure for readiness."

15 days ago • 8 min read

Geneva Unveils Four-Tier Framework for Deciding Whether Exercises Need Exercises

GENEVA — Geneva's cantonal emergency office on Thursday published a four-tier protocol governing whether a disaster exercise requires its own preparatory exercise, a question the office says it had previously been answering on a case-by-case basis. The framework follows Switzerland's participation in a major national disaster response exercise, after which the cantonal office reviewed the exercise, found it instructive, and concluded that future exercises should not proceed without advance preparation. "We had a debrief, and the debrief generated a finding, and the finding generated a recommendation," said Solange Marchetti-Duvoisin, the office's Chief of Preparatory Coordination. "At each stage it was clear what the next stage had to be." The office has not yet scheduled a single exercise under the new protocol, which is the point at which the protocol becomes relevant.

The Four Tiers

The framework divides preparation into four escalating tiers. Tier One, Pre-Exercise Notification, requires the office to notify stakeholders that an exercise is being considered. Tier Two, Pre-Exercise Consultation, requires stakeholders to be consulted on whether the notification was adequate. Tier Three, Pre-Exercise Simulation, requires a rehearsal of the consultation. Tier Four, Pre-Exercise Post-Mortem Review, requires a review of the simulation, after which the office determines whether a Tier Five is necessary. The protocol does not specify a Tier Five. It also does not specify who decides whether one is needed, which the office says is "being addressed in Tier Two."

exercise prep
  • confirm national exercise happened
  • debrief the debrief
  • draft finding (instructive)
  • approve recommendation to prep future exercises
  • tier 1 notification — who to notify?
    ask legal
  • tier 2 consultation on tier 1 adequacy
  • tier 3 simulation of consultation
  • tier 4 post-mortem of simulation
  • decide if tier 5 needed
    tbd, see tier 2
  • book first prep exercise (18 mo)
  • recheck calendar — exercise planning every other tuesday
  • review contingency plan for contingency plan revision
  • notify stakeholders (see tier 1)
Officials stand beside a cardboard staircase labeled Tier One through Tier Four while a colleague measures it on a clipboard in an empty municipal room.

Staff review the staircase ahead of Tier One notification.

CPC
Cantonal Preparatory Coordination Office, Geneva
Preparing for preparation since last quarter.
:
All Coordination Staff and Stakeholders Pending Notification
:
Solange Marchetti-Duvoisin, Chief of Preparatory Coordination
:
Thursday
:
Terminology Clarification: Pre-Exercise Activities
Key Terms:
  • •Exercise: an activity that tests readiness.
  • •Pre-Exercise: an activity that tests readiness for the exercise.
  • •Pre-Pre-Exercise: an activity that determines whether a pre-exercise is required.
  • •Pre-Pre-Pre-Exercise: an activity under review in Tier Two.

Following the national exercise, the office determined that its own exercise planning would benefit from advance preparation. The office will not be proceeding with any exercise until the prerequisite framework is approved, and the framework will not be approved until a Tier Four review is completed.

Stakeholders are reminded that the term "readiness" is reserved for use in Tier One documentation.

With continued readiness,
Solange Marchetti-Duvoisin, Chief of Preparatory Coordination

First Test Scheduled for 18 Months Out

The first preparatory exercise under the framework is scheduled to begin in 18 months, at which point the office will test whether the Tier One notification reached the people who would need to approve the Tier Two consultation. A logistics consultant hired to scope the timeline described the schedule as "realistic," noting that the framework's approval chain alone requires three separate exercises to finalize. Asked whether the framework itself had been tested, the office said it would be "piloted in a six-month trial exercise," which will itself require a Tier One notification. The trial is expected to begin once the trial has been notified.

Contingency Plan Under Review

The office's contingency plan for the framework, approved at Tuesday's planning meeting, establishes procedures for what happens if the framework fails its own review. Under the plan, a failed Tier Four review triggers a return to Tier One, and a second failure triggers a planning session to determine whether the contingency plan itself requires revision. The office confirmed that this session is scheduled for every second Tuesday, the same day and interval as the office's existing exercise planning meetings. Staff said the two meetings are distinct. Nobody has yet been able to say what they are.

More from Geneva