Poisonal
Article📍SUNSET
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Sunset District Declares Great Highway Traffic Jam a Federally Protected Wetland

The Sunset District Neighborhood Association on Tuesday classified the eastbound lane of Lincoln Way as a protected wetland after residents reported a puddle near the Irving Street crosswalk. The designation, the group said, means the city must now study the puddle for 14 years before anyone can drive through it.

11 days ago • 8 min read

Puddle Reclassified as Protected Habitat

SUNSET DISTRICT — The Sunset District Neighborhood Association has reclassified the eastbound lane of Lincoln Way between Irving Street and 19th Avenue as a protected wetland, a designation that association president Dolores Pankratz-Iwu described Thursday as "the only tool residents have left." Under the new classification, which the association filed with the Planning Department on Tuesday, the stretch of roadway containing a standing puddle near the Irving Street crosswalk is subject to a habitat assessment that the group estimates will take 14 years to complete. Until the assessment is finished, no vehicle may pass through the water, no lane may be reopened, and no change to traffic flow may be approved. "The puddle has been there since the Great Highway closed," Pankratz-Iwu said. "We are not going to be the ones who disturb it." The association is applying the same protected-habitat logic that cleared the way for Sunset Dunes to a puddle outside a Lincoln Way crosswalk.

A small puddle on a city street beside a crosswalk, marked with a sawhorse and a PROTECTED WETLAND sign, with a man in a fleece vest inspecting it with a clipboard.

Association volunteers have posted signage to protect the puddle from further disturbance.

Filing Describes Puddle as 'Irreplaceable'

In a 41-page habitat designation request filed with the Planning Department and obtained by this publication, the association describes the puddle's ecological value in terms reserved for old-growth forests. The filing refers to the water as "a critical resting site for migratory pedestrians" and notes that its "hydrologic continuity with the storm drain at Irving Street has been documented by three residents with flashlights." The request asks the city to consider "the puddle's irreplaceable character" before any "discretionary action" affecting the lane. Planning staff have forwarded the filing to the Planning Commission, which will review whether the water qualifies as a wetland under the department's own classification rules. The Planning Commission will now decide, in public session, whether a puddle is a wetland.

🗣️

Study Fee Set at $48,000

The Planning Department has set a discretionary review fee of $48,000 for the habitat assessment, payable by the applicant before the study may begin. Under the department's schedule, the fee covers a single site visit, a water sample, and a public hearing on the sample. Pankratz-Iwu said the association is prepared to pay. "We have a fundraising committee," she said. "It is mostly the same six people." Staff estimate the study will require approximately 14 years of review, a timeline the association has described as "conservative." The department has not commented on whether the puddle will still be present when the review concludes. The city has agreed to study the puddle, and the study is being paid for by the people who want to protect it.

Puddle Not Measured Since Closure

The last recorded measurement of the puddle's depth was taken on the day the Great Highway closure was approved by voters under Proposition K, which passed citywide 55-45. The measurement, filed by a resident with a yardstick, is listed in the association's appendix as "approximately one inch." Staff said they have not verified the figure and that no subsequent measurements have been submitted. The association says that is the point. "Once you measure a habitat, it becomes a number," Pankratz-Iwu said. "We would rather it remain a feeling." The puddle has been referred to the Planning Commission, which has not yet scheduled a hearing. The puddle has not been measured since the Great Highway closed, and the association would like to keep it that way.

More from Sunset