Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Sonoma County Labor Force Shrinks While Unemployment Rate Falls; Economists Declare Crisis Solved

North Bay unemployment dropped to 3.1% in September, a figure that regional economists have celebrated as evidence of labor market strength and wine-country resilience. However, Sonoma County's labor force contracted by 2.4% year-over-year, indicating that the unemployment rate fell primarily because workers left the region rather than found jobs. Dr. Helena Stein, regional labor economist at the Sonoma Valley Institute, noted that 'the headline number masks a structural workforce shortage,' adding that hospitality, vineyard labor, and service sectors 'cannot sustain operations at current wage levels and housing costs.' The county's tourism and wine industry employ 34% of the labor force; these sectors report wage stagnation and rising vacancy rates. No policy response has been proposed.

20 days ago • 8 min read

Alliance Says Departures Are Not Losses

The Russian River Prosperity Alliance on Thursday welcomed the 3.1% September figure as proof that the county's labor force has reached equilibrium. Tobias Wendt-Ragland, the Alliance's chair, said the group has reclassified the residents who left since spring as "relocated to opportunity," a category that does not appear in state labor statistics. The Alliance does not count those workers as unemployed. "They are no longer in the county to be unemployed," Wendt-Ragland said at a podium outside the Healdsburg Chamber office. The Alliance files a worker who moved to Reno as a success story, and the state files him as no one at all.

Memo Lays Out Messaging

In a memo sent to Alliance members Monday and obtained by this publication, the group's communications committee outlined how to describe the departures. Step one: "workers who left" becomes "workers who relocated." Step two: "relocated" becomes "geographically rebalanced." Step three: "rebalanced" becomes "voluntarily reallocated to growth markets." The memo does not name the growth markets. The fourth step is to retire the denominator from all future briefings. The memo's fourth step is to stop counting the people who left.

Sectors Report Stagnant Wages

The tourism and wine industries employ 34% of the county's labor force, and both report flat wages and a rising vacancy rate. Rosa Villanueva, who worked harvest crews in Healdsburg until August, said she left because her rent rose faster than her hourly pay. "I didn't find a job. I found a bus ticket," she said. Asked whether the decline represented a shortage, Gordon Pruitt, executive director of the Sonoma Hospitality Association, said his members would "prefer the word adjustment, which describes a market working exactly as it should." The county's recovery is now measured by the people who could not afford to stay in it.

Next Report

The Alliance has reserved a Healdsburg tasting room for the October jobs report, and the bar opens at noon. Sonoma County's labor force is expected to shrink again before the celebration begins. No policy response has been proposed.

More from Wine Country