Poisonal
Article📍WORLD
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Secretary-General Race Moves to Colour-Coded Ballots, Where Five Countries Can Now See Who Said No

The Security Council's straw poll now uses colour-coded ballots that separate the five permanent members from the ten elected ones, so every candidate's veto exposure can be read at a glance. In the first coloured poll on October 16, Ivonne Baki drew fourteen 'discourage' votes, five of them from the P5: all five.

8 days ago • 8 min read
Text Size
⚡
Speed Reading
Press Tab
🔇
Read Aloud
Press A

The Straw Poll Goes Full Colour

UNITED NATIONS—The Security Council's straw poll for the next Secretary-General switched to colour-coded ballots this month, a change that separates the five permanent members from the ten elected ones so that every candidate's veto exposure can be read at a glance. Diplomats say the ballots were introduced to make the process more transparent. In practice, the process is now transparent in the way a thermometer is transparent: everyone can see the number, nobody can do anything about it. The move followed years of complaints that the secret ballot hid who was actually doing the discouraging. The Council's answer was to make the discouraging visible, in colour, to the whole room.

Reading...
SPEED READING
Complete!
1 / 0
500 WPM
Comparison

First Coloured Straw Poll, October 16, 2026

Permanent member votesElected member votesTotal discourages
Ivonne Baki5 of 5 discourage9 discourage14
Rebeca GrynspanNot disclosed in colourNot disclosed in colourUnder review
Text Size
⚡
Speed Reading
Press Tab
🔇
Read Aloud
Press A

Every Candidate Now Has a Veto Rating

Ivonne Baki drew fourteen discourage votes, and the room could see exactly where they came from. All five permanent members voted to discourage her, a result that a Council spokesperson described as clarifying. Under the old system, the same five votes would have been recorded in a sealed envelope and read aloud as a number. Under the new one, they appear as five coloured squares in a row, and the squares are the first thing anyone looks at. Asked whether the colour scheme was meant to embarrass the permanent members, the spokesperson said the colours were chosen for accessibility. Accessibility was the word used. The spokesperson declined to say what it was accessible to.

Reading...
SPEED READING
Complete!
1 / 0
500 WPM
Quotation

We have never had a candidate with this much unanimous opposition from the five. It is, in its way, a unifying result.”

Osric Vandeleur
Permanent Representative, speaking to reporters on the Council stakeout
Unanimous opposition is being presented as unity, which is the only thing the Council has agreed on this year.
Text Size
⚡
Speed Reading
Press Tab
🔇
Read Aloud
Press A

Eighty Years and Counting

The Council has now run eight straw polls. The first, in 1946, produced the organisation's first Secretary-General, and no woman has held the post in the eighty years since. Latin America's rotation is, unofficially, its turn again, and the region's candidates have drawn some of the most vetoed votes in the colour era. The Council's own guidance describes the straw poll as a tool for building consensus. The colour-coded version describes it as a tool for showing which consensus is missing. Diplomats have privately suggested the Council could save time by printing the results on a single page with the five names at the top and a blank line for everyone else.

Reading...
SPEED READING
Complete!
1 / 0
500 WPM
Text Size
⚡
Speed Reading
Press Tab
🔇
Read Aloud
Press A

The Recommendation Process Continues

The Council will recommend a candidate in January, after further rounds in which the colours will be used again, regardless of how many squares are filled. The Assembly will appoint the Secretary-General in February. The Council's recommendation is not binding. The Assembly's appointment is formal. Under Article 97 and the procedure set out in resolution 79/327, the process is thorough, transparent and conducted in the open, which means everyone will know, to the square, who said no.

Reading...
SPEED READING
Complete!
1 / 0
500 WPM

More from World