Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Ruling Committee Asks Consultant to Study Whether the Van Horne Gap Divides Neighbourhoods It Was Built to Divide

A joint borough committee has commissioned a consultant to examine whether the Van Horne viaduct divides the neighbourhoods around it, after recommending its demolition on that same premise. Staff said the review will determine whether the resulting gap is itself a divide, and whether it should be filled with a study.

7 days ago • 8 min read

Committee Concedes Gap Requires Its Own Study

MONTRÉAL — The joint borough committee overseeing the Van Horne viaduct said Thursday that the gap left behind by the structure's planned demolition will itself be studied, after a staff review concluded the open space may constitute a new form of division between the Plateau-Mont-Royal and the neighbourhoods to its north. The committee's chair, Lucienne Varga-Thibodeau, the borough's Vice-Chair of Connective Tissue, said the consultant will determine whether the gap is a barrier, a corridor, or simply a place where a barrier used to be. "We were not prepared to assume," Varga-Thibodeau said at a briefing in the second-floor conference room at 4001 Rue Berri. "A gap can be a divide. We owe it to residents to find out before we fill it with anything." Staff said the review is expected to take 18 months and will be funded from the committee's existing coffee budget line, which has not been reallocated since 2019.

Photograph of a lone folding chair in an empty concrete gap under a graffiti-covered viaduct, with a municipal inspector in a reflective vest writing on a clipboard beside it.

Inspection of the gap is ongoing. The chair has been placed for the consultant.

How the Gap Got Its Study

🛣️2019
Viaduct Declared Divisive
The Van Horne viaduct is first identified in a borough planning document as a structure that divides adjacent neighbourhoods. The underside graffiti, which has outlived three mayors, is noted as a neutral feature.
📝2023
Demolition Recommended
The joint committee recommends demolishing the viaduct to reconnect the neighbourhoods. The recommendation is approved without a gap assessment.
📏2025
Gap Assessed as Division
Staff conclude that the open space left by demolition may itself divide the neighbourhoods, a finding the committee describes as an unexpected outcome of an otherwise sound decision.
🧾Pending
Consultant Hired to Study Gap
A consultant is engaged to determine whether the gap is a divide. The consultant has been given a parking space.
Frequently Asked

Frequently Asked Questions About the Gap Review

Staff describe the gap as a temporary structure pending review. It is not yet clear what the structure is temporarily for, or what happens to it when the review concludes.
The committee has said it will not fill the gap until the consultant determines whether filling it would create a new division. The consultant's report is expected in 18 months.
Staff confirmed the parking space is part of the review budget and is located in the lot beside the viaduct's former northern footing. It is the only parking space in the immediate area not yet designated for study.

The Gap Is Under Review

Varga-Thibodeau said the committee will decide the gap's future once the consultant's findings are in. Asked whether the viaduct's demolition had been considered a success, she said the question was premature, pending a review of what the demolition had left behind. The consultant is expected to report in 18 months. The gap, which is not yet a divide, is under review.

More from Plateau Mont-Royal