Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Photo Saint-Germain Festival Declares Free Art Is the Only Acceptable Art, Reports Several Visitors Who Tried to Pay

The free PhotoSaintGermain festival returned Monday to more than thirty venues, and organizers confirmed that paid photography has been formally banned from the neighborhood. A visitor who attempted to purchase a print was directed to a notice requesting that he take it home "in spirit," and a gallery owner said the policy is working beautifully, since the only people buying prints now are the ones who were given them.

12 days ago • 8 min read

Festival Bars Paid Photography From Neighborhood

PARIS — The free PhotoSaintGermain festival returned Monday to more than thirty venues across the Saint-Germain-des-Prés quarter, and organizers confirmed that the sale of photographs has been formally prohibited for the duration of the event. Under the festival's revised charter, a photograph bought is a photograph stolen from the neighborhood, according to the program's opening remarks, delivered by festival director Hervé Lasalle-Brunet, a man who calls the festival his life's work, and the festival has not yet found out. Lasalle-Brunet described the ban as an extension of the festival's founding principle that access to art belongs to everyone, and said the logic follows naturally: if the work is free to see, it is also free to keep, and anyone who reaches for a wallet has misunderstood the gift. Photographs sold during the festival have been reclassified as a form of enclosure.

Visitor Attempts Purchase, Is Redirected to Notice

A visitor attempting to buy a print at the festival's main venue on Rue Bonaparte was directed instead to a notice requesting that he take the photograph home "in spirit." The notice, printed on card stock and affixed to a table of unsold prints, reads in full: "PhotoSaintGermain is free. Photography is a shared inheritance. Please do not pay. Please take it home in spirit." The visitor, a retired typesetter from Lyon, said he had been prepared to pay forty euros. He said he was not prepared to be asked to carry something away while feeling guilty about it. The cashier on duty declined to accept the forty euros, saying the register was closed to the public for reasons of spiritual integrity.

Gallery Owner Reports Policy Working "Beautifully"

At the Galerie Morcel on Rue Jacob, owner Solène Varaud said the policy is working beautifully. "The only people with prints now are the people we gave them to," Varaud said, adding that her gallery has distributed more than two hundred photographs since Monday and has sold none. Asked whether the gallery had considered covering costs, she said that covering costs was precisely the kind of thinking the festival had asked the neighborhood to leave behind. The espresso counter two doors down, which still charges for coffee, is quietly regarded across the quarter as a festival sponsor, a designation no one has been able to confirm and no one has been willing to contest.

Festival Economies
The Gifted Print
Photographia donata
Monday through the end of the festival
  • ·
    Free at point of entry
  • ·
    Cannot be returned for credit
  • ·
    Carries a notice requesting it be taken in spirit
  • ·
    Bears no price, and therefore no meaning
  • ·
    Found mostly in the hands of people who did not ask for it
  • ·
    Resists resale by definition
Quiet, and faintly apologetic.
Saint-Germain-des-Prés, Paris VIe
Gallery counters, café tables, the lobbies of more than thirty venues
Similar species
The sold print, which is now considered a theft of the neighborhood's gratitude.

Organizers Propose Admission Fee for Not Paying

Festival organizers announced Thursday that they are exploring a modest admission fee for visitors who wish to attend the festival without buying anything, a measure they describe as a way to keep the neighborhood's generosity sustainable. The proposed fee would be payable at the entrance, and the proceeds would be donated to the festival's own free-admission fund. A spokesperson, speaking on background from the festival office, said the proposal had been received warmly, adding that the only objection so far had come from a visitor who asked whether he was being charged to be told he was free. Lasalle-Brunet was unavailable for comment, having reportedly stepped out to pay for a coffee, which he described as a private matter between himself and the espresso counter.

Festival Ledger Closes With One Remaining Entry

The festival's internal ledger, circulated to venue coordinators and obtained by this publication, lists revenue for the event as zero, expenditures as thirty-one venues, and a single outstanding line item for "espresso, unclassified." The photographs have been given to the neighborhood in perpetuity, and the neighborhood has been asked to stop asking for them back. No visitor has been able to leave with anything but a sense of gratitude.

More from Saint-Germain-des-Pres