Poisonal
Article📍SUNSET
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Outer Sunset Fog Bank Files Discretionary Review Against Sunlight

A fog bank parked over the Outer Sunset filed a discretionary review Monday objecting to a proposed sunbeam scheduled to break through its western edge for 40 minutes next Tuesday. The fog's attorney said the sunbeam would set a precedent for light-based development in a neighborhood that has never permitted it. The Planning Department has scheduled a hearing for a date that falls after the sunbeam has already passed.

11 days ago • 8 min read

Fog Bank Files Discretionary Review

SUNSET DISTRICT — A fog bank parked over the Outer Sunset filed a discretionary review with the San Francisco Planning Department on Monday, objecting to a sunbeam scheduled to break through its western edge for forty minutes next Tuesday. The filing, which runs eleven pages and bears the fog's registered neighborhood-character designation, asserts that the sunbeam would constitute an unpermitted intrusion into a low-rise, fog-dependent streetscape. The fog's attorney, who spoke on condition that the fog be identified only as "the applicant," said the sunbeam would set a precedent for light-based development in a neighborhood that has never permitted it. The fog has been present in the Outer Sunset continuously since before the neighborhood had streets.

Public Comment, Planning Commission Pre-Hearing Call
Planning Department Pre-Application Line | Monday, 3:12 p.m.
PLANNER:
Thank you for calling. Can you state the nature of your objection?
FOG'S ATTORNEY:
The applicant objects to the sunbeam. The applicant has always been here. The applicant does not want a sunbeam reading as a light-based development on the block.
PLANNER:
The sunbeam is scheduled for 40 minutes. Would a shorter sunbeam be acceptable?
FOG'S ATTORNEY:
One hesitates to say "acceptable," given the neighborhood's history. Let's say "tolerated." Yes. Tolerated, for no longer than the current approved duration.
PLANNER:
The hearing is set for the 19th.
FOG'S ATTORNEY:
[long pause] Which is after Tuesday.
A gray fog bank over a row of pastel houses with a single folding chair on the sidewalk and an attorney in a blazer holding a folder.

The applicant's chair, reserved for public comment, Outer Sunset.

Hearing Scheduled After Sunbeam

The Planning Department confirmed Wednesday that the hearing on the discretionary review will take place on the 19th, a date that falls six days after the sunbeam has already passed. A department spokesperson said the scheduling was "consistent with standard review timelines" and that the sunbeam "was not contingent on the outcome." Asked whether the sunbeam could be delayed pending the hearing, the spokesperson said the sunbeam "is not something we can reschedule." The sunbeam's approval was issued for the following year.

Commission Approves Compromise

At its Thursday session, the Planning Commission voted 4-0 to approve a ten-minute sunbeam as a compromise, reducing the original forty-minute allotment by three-quarters. Commissioner Dolores Pelletier-Abara, presiding, called the outcome "a responsible middle ground that respects neighborhood character." The fog's attorney was reached by phone and said the applicant would "accept the compromise with reservations, and under protest." The approved sunbeam is scheduled for a future date, pending the applicant's continued presence.

Update

The sunbeam was approved for a future date. The fog has since been upzoned.

More from Sunset