Reminder: our toasties are now time-based. Every minute of waiting is 40p, billed at the table. Complaints about the surcharge are also surcharged. Thank you for understanding.
Old Street Café Prices £20 Toastie by the Minute of Waiting
A café on Old Street has begun charging for its £20 toastie at 40 pence per minute spent waiting for it, the owner said Monday. Proprietor Lysander Kettering-Bo said the rate reflects the slow-cook method used for the bread. A customer who ordered at 2pm was charged £22.80 for the same sandwich after a seven-minute delay.
Café Introduces Per-Minute Surcharge on £20 Toastie
A café on Old Street has begun charging customers for the time they spend waiting for its £20 toastie, at a rate of 40 pence per minute, the owner said Monday. Proprietor Lysander Kettering-Bo said the surcharge was introduced after a wave of complaints about the wait, and that the fee is now applied to the toastie itself. "The sandwich was always priced for its time," Kettering-Bo said from behind the counter on Tuesday. "We have simply stopped pretending otherwise." The café's menu now lists the toastie as a time-based sandwich, with a note that the bread is sourced from a bakery two streets away, a distance the owner cited as the reason for the slow cook. Customers who complained about the wait are now charged for complaining.
Old Street Toastie Regulars 🧠

The café's new timer is zip-tied to the toastie press.
Customer Declines Further Comment
Asked whether the surcharge applied to customers who had already paid, Kettering-Bo said he could not comment on individual accounts, on the bread's transit time, or on the phrase "per minute" as used in the menu's footer. Derek Pilling, the accountant who first disputed the £2.80 charge, declined to comment on whether he had been surcharged for the dispute. He has since filed a complaint, which has been logged and will be billed at his next visit.
