Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Napa County Expands Vineyard Removal Program After Realizing Pulling Up Vines Is Cheaper Than Selling Wine

Napa County supervisors voted Tuesday to expand incentive payments for vineyard removal to 8,200 additional acres, a decision that follows California's statewide pullout of 9,847 acres in 2025. The county's agricultural economist, Dr. Patricia Moreno, stated that 'the removal incentive now exceeds the marginal revenue of a third-tier Cabernet,' making ripping out mature vines economically rational. 'Growers are choosing to be paid to stop growing,' Dr. Moreno said. The county has not yet determined what to plant on the cleared land, though a working group has suggested 'commercial marijuana cultivation' and 'a very large parking lot.'

19 days ago • 8 min read

Growers Line Up for Payment

Under the expanded program, growers receive a per-acre payment for pulling vines, and the rate is set by the county's removal schedule. Teodor Vasquez-Lindqvist, 61, has farmed 40 acres of Cabernet off the Silverado Trail since 1989. He filed his application at the Agricultural Commissioner's office on Imola Avenue in Napa on Monday and was approved Wednesday. “I'm being paid more to pull out the vines than I ever got for the grapes,” Vasquez-Lindqvist said. “My father would have had me arrested.” He said the removal crew is scheduled to arrive in two weeks, and that the county's paperwork asked him to confirm the vines were 'no longer economically productive.' He checked the box.

Office Revises Its Terms

In a memo sent to Agricultural Commissioner's staff last month and obtained by this publication, the office revised the program's language:

“Vineyard removal” is now voluntary canopy transition.
“Pulled vines” is now “reclaimed rootstock.”
“Unsold grapes” is now “unharvested inventory.”

The memo lists one program goal: a county in which the word “vineyard” does not appear in the program. The memo's stated goal is a county in which the word “vineyard” does not appear in the program.

Replacement Crops Under Review by the Napa County Post-Removal Land Working Group

  • +Commercial marijuana cultivation is already permitted on agriculturally zoned parcels, and existing growers already own the drip irrigation.
  • +A very large parking lot requires no irrigation, which the working group called “a meaningful savings in a drought year.”
  • +A parking lot generates revenue on every day the county is open.

  • −Parking revenue is not a crop, and the county's own definition of agriculture does not list it.
  • −The marijuana option would be regulated by the same county office that wrote the removal payments.
  • −No working group member has been asked to taste the parking lot.

County Declines to Characterize Program

The county does not describe the removal program as a subsidy for industry failure. Calloway Brisbane-Ochoa, the county's Assistant Administrator for Land Transition, called it “a voluntary transition in a changing market.” Asked whether any grower had received more from the county to remove a vine than the vine could have sold for, Brisbane-Ochoa declined to comment. The county also declined to comment on the number of times the word “collapse” appears in its board packet for Tuesday's vote, the number of vines pulled since the program opened, and why the 1990 blocks are being removed first. Brisbane-Ochoa said the county is “not in the business of deciding what grows.” The county declined to comment on three questions. The county described the removal payments in its board packet as economically rational.

Payments Begin

Applications opened Monday, and approvals were issued by Wednesday. The county's public dashboard lists “vines pulled” under the heading projected yield, and the six-day approval is listed as a program success. The county has budgeted the removal payments through 2026. The working group's final report is due in 2031.

More from Wine Country