Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Mayor Lurie Declares Family Zoning Plan 'Housing Crisis Solved'; Expects Zero New Units

Mayor Daniel Lurie announced a press release Thursday stating that his Family Zoning Plan has successfully addressed San Francisco's housing crisis, expecting the policy to produce approximately zero net new housing units while upzoning Pacific Heights, Presidio Heights, and "strategically selected western neighborhoods." The plan's primary mechanism—single interior stairwell allowance under limited conditions—will apply to approximately two properties citywide, both currently held by land trusts awaiting development financing.

1 month ago • 8 min read

SAN FRANCISCO — Mayor Daniel Lurie announced in a press release Thursday that his Family Zoning Plan has solved the city's housing crisis, a claim the release makes once, in its second paragraph, and does not repeat. The office projects the plan will produce zero net new housing units. The mayor's office described the outcome as "a meaningful step toward the city we all want to build," and said the plan will take effect in Pacific Heights, Presidio Heights and "strategically selected western neighborhoods" on a timeline the release did not specify. The plan's central mechanism, a single interior stairwell allowance, will apply under limited conditions to approximately two properties citywide.

What the Plan Does

The stairwell allowance permits a second interior staircase in certain multi-unit buildings that meet minimum lot-width requirements. Planning staff reviewed the city's parcel records and identified two lots that qualify, both held by community land trusts that are still waiting on development financing before breaking ground. Neither trust has submitted plans that depend on the allowance. Neither trust had heard of it until this week. The remaining upzoning raises height limits on roughly 1,400 parcels in the western neighborhoods. Under current construction costs, the city's own feasibility memo concludes that no market-rate developer can profitably build on the newly permitted height, which the memo describes as "a sincere gesture toward the future."

housing plan todo
  • announce family zoning plan
  • say "housing crisis solved" (once only)
    not twice, the press office was clear
  • upzone pac heights + presidio hts
  • find the two lots (stairwell thing)
    staff found them Tuesday
  • ask land trusts for comment
    they have not returned our calls
  • confirm 1,400 parcels is a real number
  • schedule next housing press conference
  • reference this plan as proof reform doesn't work
  • build something
SF
City & County of San Francisco, Office of the Mayor
Building the City Together
:
Department Heads, Planning Commission
:
Garrett Vollmer, Deputy Director of Housing Messaging
:
Thursday
:
Talking Points: Family Zoning Plan Success Narrative

Please use the following framing in all public contact regarding the Family Zoning Plan. Reporters will ask how many units the plan produces. Do not answer with a number.

Approved Language:
  • •"The Family Zoning Plan is a historic step toward solving our housing crisis."
  • •"Every stairwell counts."
  • •"We are not going to let the perfect be the enemy of the press release."
Terminology Guide:
  • •"Housing units" → "pathways to housing"
  • •"Zero new units" → "no change to baseline projections, which is a win"
  • •"Two properties" → "a pilot cohort"
  • •"Upzoning wealthy neighborhoods" → "neighborhood-scale equity"
Do Not Say:
  • •"the plan does nothing"
  • •"two lots"
  • •"the land trusts have not been consulted"
  • •"Mission Street"
Thank you for your continued discipline.
Garrett Vollmer, Deputy Director of Housing Messaging
A single folding chair and podium stand alone on an empty warehouse floor beneath a banner reading FAMILY ZONING PLAN.

The press event for the city's new pathways to housing, held at the mayor's office's Shelter Network site.

Frequently Asked

Frequently Asked Questions About the Family Zoning Plan

The Office of the Mayor projects zero net new units, a figure the office describes as "no change to baseline projections." The office notes that the plan has been called a success regardless of its unit count, which the press release describes as an intentional feature of the policy's ambition.
The plan applies to Pacific Heights, Presidio Heights and "strategically selected western neighborhoods." Staff declined to identify the selected neighborhoods, citing ongoing site selection discussions. Residents of the eastern and southern districts are encouraged to remain patient.
The mayor's office has stated that the crisis is solved. The office has not stated what the crisis now looks like, nor whether anyone is living in it.
Only if you own one of the two qualifying lots and your lot is held by a community land trust that is awaiting development financing. Both trusts were contacted for comment and did not respond by press time.

More from Pacific Heights