Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Le Petit Elephant Childcare Victory Rewrites Environmental Law to Protect Napa Daycare From Future Environmental Scrutiny

A Napa childcare center's legal battle with neighbors over environmental review requirements prompted California to narrow the scope of CEQA exemptions, effectively legislating that future daycare expansions in wine-country neighborhoods will face reduced regulatory oversight. The win was celebrated as a triumph for childcare access, though internal communications from the daycare's legal team revealed the actual dispute concerned a planned tripling of capacity on a property previously zoned agricultural—and the law's passage ensures similar expansions elsewhere face lighter scrutiny.

19 days ago • 8 min read

Neighbors Object to Triple Capacity

Le Petit Elephant asked Napa County for permission to triple its capacity on a parcel zoned agricultural. Neighbors filed objections under the California Environmental Quality Act, the state's environmental review law, and asked for a full drainage study.

Ruth Ondarza, 67, a retired county public works inspector who lives on a dirt lane east of the property, said she had asked for the study twice. Stormwater from the site, she said, runs downhill toward a seasonal creek she has photographed for 22 years. Nobody came out to look at the ditch, Ondarza said.

Ondarza's objections were filed, logged, and moved to a different calendar.

LPE
Le Petit Elephant Childcare, Inc.
Little Hands, Big Future
:
Site Leadership and Communications Staff
:
Corinne Abernathy-Sol, Partner, Hale & Brugh LLP (outside counsel)
:
Tuesday, March 4
:
Post-Ruling Messaging: Napa Parcel

Following the Legislature's passage of the Childcare Accessibility Act, all staff should use the approved language below in every external and internal communication. Please do not improvise.

Approved Terminology:
  • •Expansion becomes access
  • •Tripling of capacity becomes meeting documented community demand
  • •Agricultural parcel becomes a site with a long history of community use
  • •Neighbor objections become 'the removal of frivolous CEQA challenges'
  • •Stormwater becomes site drainage

Neighbor objections are to be described as frivolous, regardless of their merit.

Do Not Say:
  • •Environmental review
  • •Vineyard
  • •Triple
  • •Ondarza
Precedent Inquiries:
  • •Refer all questions to counsel.
  • •Do not confirm or deny that other sites are similar.
  • •The goal is that the question does not come up again.
Please direct all questions to counsel.
Corinne Abernathy-Sol, Partner, Hale & Brugh LLP
Four officials in suits cut a red ribbon between vineyard posts beside a lone plastic children's slide standing in dirt.

Officials cut a ribbon at the parcel's former vineyard row.

Frequently Asked

Frequently Asked Questions: Childcare Accessibility Act

The Act streamlines review for qualifying childcare facilities. Streamlining is a term of art meaning that neighbor objections no longer trigger the full review process. Projects that serve children no longer have to survive the review that neighbors used to invoke.
The Act applies to childcare facilities regardless of the zoning designation of the underlying parcel. The Act does not use the word vineyard.
Drainage is addressed under the Act's site plan provisions. Questions about runoff should be directed to the applicant.
Yes.

Memo Language Appears in Bill

The phrase 'removal of frivolous CEQA challenges' appears in the daycare's internal memo and, word for word, in the legislative summary of the bill published in Sacramento. A spokesperson for State Senator Dale Hinckley-Moss said the language was drafted with input from stakeholders and declined to identify them.

At a March board meeting of Le Petit Elephant, a board member asked whether the outcome could set a precedent for other wine-country real-estate conversions. The question does not appear in the approved minutes.

The minutes record the board's only discussion of precedent as a question about parking.

Runoff Discovered

Ondarza later reviewed the expansion plan and found that the facility's stormwater runoff would discharge directly into a tributary of the creek she has photographed since 2003. No one in the county asked the tributary what it thought of the plan. Its official title is the Childcare Accessibility Act.

More from Wine Country