Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Joint Committee Recommends Demolishing Van Horne Viaduct, Then Commissions Study on Whether the Gap Divides Neighbourhoods

A joint committee of the Plateau-Mont-Royal and Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie boroughs said Tuesday it will recommend demolishing the Van Horne viaduct. The committee has already hired a consultant to determine whether the resulting gap will divide the neighbourhoods. The consultant's study is expected to outlast the demolition by several years.

15 days ago • 8 min read

A joint committee of the Plateau-Mont-Royal and Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie boroughs has formally recommended that the city tear down the Van Horne viaduct, the rail overpass that has connected the two neighbourhoods since 1914, citing the bridge's role in dividing the community. The recommendation carries an unusual condition: before the demolition proceeds, the committee has hired an outside consultant to determine whether the resulting gap will divide the neighbourhoods. The consultant's mandate, according to the committee's terms of reference, is to study the gap from "both sides." A borough planner, speaking on background, said the phrase was chosen deliberately. "It's a neutral term," the planner said. "We didn't want to presume which side the gap would be on." The consultant's study is expected to outlast the demolition by several years.

Two officials in dark coats stand before a sign marking an empty median as a consultation zone, while a municipal worker holds a clipboard beside a barricade.

Officials inspect the designated consultation zone, a median that has not yet been designated for anything.

PM
Plateau-Mont-Royal Borough, Office of Urban Mobility
Connecting Communities, Pending Study
:
All Borough Staff, Urban Planning Division
:
Hélène Dufresne-Achebe, Director of Interjurisdictional Coordination
:
March 4, 2026
:
Terminology Guidance for the Van Horne Initiative

In anticipation of public questions following the joint committee's recommendation, staff are reminded to use the approved terminology below when speaking with residents, reporters, or the consultant.

Approved Terms:
  • •Viaduct → structure, pending assessment
  • •Divide → interface, pending assessment
  • •Gap → opportunity for dialogue
  • •Demolition → a conversation about the structure's future
Talking Points:
  • •The committee has not decided to demolish the structure.
  • •The committee has decided to recommend demolition of the structure, which is a separate matter.
  • •The consultant will determine whether the gap divides the neighbourhoods. Staff should not presume the outcome.
  • •Staff should not presume the outcome of the consultation either.
Residents Who Ask Where They Will Cross:
  • •Refer them to the consultation.
  • •If the consultation has not concluded, refer them to the study.
  • •If the study has not concluded, the structure will have been removed, and the question of crossing will have been resolved by the removal.
Thank you for your continued commitment to the neighbourhoods we serve.
Hélène Dufresne-Achebe, Director of Interjurisdictional Coordination

The consultant, a firm that has never worked on a bridge, has been asked to deliver a preliminary finding in the fall. The Plateau-Mont-Royal planner who first suggested the "both sides" framing said the viaduct itself will be removed in the second half of next year, in time for the community to be present at the ribbon-cutting for the consultation's first phase. Residents on both sides of the rail corridor have argued for years that the bridge is the only thing they share. The two boroughs have each sent staff to the other's council meetings to take notes. Asked what the committee's next step would be if the gap is found to divide the neighbourhoods, the chair said the committee would form a second committee to study the first. The viaduct is scheduled to come down in the year the study is due.

More from Plateau Mont-Royal