Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Historic District Rules Require Approval to Replace a Window, Not a Neighborhood

Homeowners in Cool Spring-Tilton Park must receive approval from the Design Review and Preservation Commission before changing their windows, a rule the commission says "stabilizes property values." One block away, in a non-historic area, the same rule does not apply, and a developer has already demolished two houses for townhomes.

10 days ago • 8 min read

Commission Says Window Rules Protect Property Values as Block Next Door Is Cleared

Homeowners in Cool Spring-Tilton Park who wish to replace a window must first receive approval from the Design Review and Preservation Commission, which approves all exterior changes to buildings in the designated historic district. The commission said the review process "stabilizes property values." Commission staffer Gordon Abernathy-Feld, deputy coordinator for exterior fenestration, said applications are evaluated against the Secretary of the Interior's standards and typically take between five and nine months. Residents who install an unapproved window face penalties under the district ordinance. One block east, outside the boundary, the same review does not apply. A developer there has demolished two houses this year to make room for townhomes, and no application was required because no one asked the question of whether the houses should stay.

Commission Requests Written Justification for Ground-Floor Sash Replacement

In a letter to a resident on Tilton Avenue dated last month and obtained by this publication, the commission asked the homeowner to address the following:

1. Whether the existing wood sash is original to the 1911 construction.
2. Whether the proposed replacement sash reproduces the muntin profile to the satisfaction of staff.
3. Whether the resident has considered that the window is "a character-defining feature of the streetscape."

The letter did not address the two houses one block east that are now a construction site. Abernathy-Feld said the commission does not review demolition outside its boundary, adding that "the window is what we're here to protect." Asked whether a demolished house could be a character-defining feature, he said the question was outside the commission's jurisdiction.

A framed wood window stands alone on a cleared lot where two houses once were, flanked by three officials in vests holding a clipboard.

The window has been approved. The houses were not reviewed.

Developer Says Townhomes Will Be Nominated for Historic Designation

Reached by phone, Marcus Tieri-Okonkwo, managing principal of Tilton Ridge Development, said the company intends to apply for historic designation for the completed townhomes once construction is finished. "We believe the new structures will contribute to the historic character of the area," Tieri-Okonkwo said. Asked whether the demolished houses had contributed to that character, he said the company had "responsibly documented" the properties before removal. The documentation consisted of a single photograph, taken from the sidewalk, that did not show the rear of either house. Commission staff confirmed no application for demolition was received because none is required outside the district boundary.

Hot Tip

If You Want to Replace a Window, Prepare to Be Asked About Your Feelings

Commission review of window replacement is a close reading of one element. Applicants who bring a sash profile drawing but no history of the house tend to be sent back for a second round. Bring photographs of the original window in place.
In practice
Submit a sash profile drawing dimensioned to the sixteenth of an inch
Attach the 1911 permit record if you can locate it
Document the existing muntin pattern before any work is proposed

Commission Refers Window Question for Further Study

The Tilton Avenue application has been referred to the commission's Subcommittee on Fenestration for further study. The subcommittee is expected to meet in the spring, approximately eight months after the application was filed. The houses one block east are scheduled to be completed in the fall. The window has been referred to the commission for further study.

More from West Side