Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Georgetown Repeals Tiny Homes Ordinance After Discovering Its Tiny Homes Are Bigger Than Its Lawyers

Georgetown's town council voted to repeal its cottage housing ordinance amid a lawsuit, saying the decision was made to avoid a legal exposure that had grown beyond the size of the dwellings. The council noted the homes had been approved on the basis of their small footprint, a standard the litigation has since described as "generous." Officials said the 20-unit East Market Street project will proceed on schedule.

8 days ago • 8 min read

Council Repeals Ordinance Governing Homes Now Larger Than Its Legal Budget

GEORGETOWN, Del. — The Town Council voted 4-1 Tuesday to repeal the cottage housing ordinance that permitted the 20-unit East Market Street project, citing what Council Member Harlan Pruitt, a member of the council's Ordinance Review Committee, called "a legal exposure that has grown beyond the size of the dwellings." The ordinance, adopted in 2021, capped each unit at 480 square feet. The council noted the homes had been approved on the basis of that small footprint, a standard the litigation has since described as "generous." The lawsuit, brought by Springboard Delaware in Court of Chancery, has already exceeded the combined square footage of the 20 units by a margin the town clerk described as "not something we planned for." Pruitt, reached at his desk, declined to specify the figure but said the council had "done the math on a per-foot basis and it was not close."

Legal Fees Per Square Foot of Tiny Home

fees/sqft
42.9Legal cost per square foot of housing
At 42.9 per square foot, the litigation is priced as a luxury material, and the homes are the cheapest thing on the block.
Which slider matters more right now
One more step of Litigation spend to date (412,000 USD → 412,001 USD) would raise Legal cost per square foot of housing by 0.000104 USD per sq ft. One more step of Total square footage of 20 units (9,600 sq ft → 9,601 sq ft) would cut Legal cost per square foot of housing by 0.00447 USD per sq ft. Total square footage of 20 units is the bigger lever at these settings.
If Litigation spend to date were…
At 0 USD, Legal cost per square foot of housing would be 0 USD per sq ft; at 1,000,000 USD, 104.2; at 2,000,000 USD, 208.3; at 3,000,000 USD, 312.5; at 4,000,000 USD, 416.7; and at 5,000,000 USD, 520.8. You are at 412,000 USD: 42.9 USD per sq ft.

Council Clarifies Ratio Applies Only to Projects Under Twenty Units

Asked whether the calculation should be applied uniformly across the town's housing stock, Pruitt said the council had "considered a proportionality standard" but ultimately exempted the 20-unit East Market Street project, which proceeds on schedule. Pruitt said the exemption was necessary because the project "is at the threshold where the ratio stops being a useful tool." Two smaller infill proposals on Mulberry Street, each under ten units, were withdrawn Wednesday after the council adopted the same proportionality test for them. Neither developer responded to requests for comment. The Mulberry Street parcels are currently listed as "available for legal review."

A small cottage on a trailer in a municipal lot, with suited men cutting a ribbon beside it as a stack of legal binders is wheeled past.

Town officials mark the start of the lawyers' cottage, which is now the larger structure.

Council Offers Vacant Cottage to Litigants for Settlement Talks

Pruitt confirmed Thursday that the council has offered one of the unbuilt 480-square-foot units, which the town has not yet constructed, as a neutral room for settlement negotiations between Springboard Delaware and the town's outside counsel. The offer, first reported in a council email obtained by this publication, states that the unit "may be used for depositions, sidebar conferences and other proceedings that require a space the parties agree is too small for any one of them to enter comfortably." Springboard's attorney declined to say whether the proposal was accepted. Pruitt said the cottage will be furnished with one folding table and a sign reading "Recess."

Developer Says Project Remains on Schedule Pending Litigation Outcome

Carl Ostrander, a principal of the East Market Street developer's ownership group, said Friday that construction is expected to begin on schedule, "contingent on the lawyers finishing before the homes do." Asked what happens if the litigation outlasts the 20 units, Ostrander said the company had "budgeted for both possibilities, and in both cases the homes will be ready." The ordinance, which the council repealed Tuesday, will remain in effect for the East Market Street project under a grandfather clause. The lawsuit is scheduled for its next status conference in the spring. The cottages are not expected to be finished by then.

Footprint Limit Was Written By Someone Who Never Measured a Bedroom

The 480-square-foot cap was drafted in 2021 by a committee that, according to its minutes, did not include any member who had slept in a bed smaller than a king. The minutes describe the limit as "aspirational" and note that a motion to raise it to 500 square feet was tabled because "the lawyers are not ready to discuss it." The town's current zoning code still refers to the cottages as "dwelling units of modest scale." The lawsuit describes the same units as "a disputed parcel of approximately one cottage." The town has not disputed the description.

The Cottage Remains Unbuilt

The lawyers have been assigned a cottage.

More from Forty Acres