Poisonal
Article📍GENEVA
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Geneva Council of State Advances New Rights Framework; Scope Remains Under Review

The Geneva Council of State released a proposal Wednesday to strengthen protections for people with disabilities, with officials emphasizing their commitment to determining which rights would be eligible for strengthening once legal parameters are finalized. A spokesperson said the canton had 'begun the important work of identifying which improvements are improvements,' with a timeline for specifics yet to be announced.

15 days ago • 8 min read

Council Announces Framework, Declines to Name Its Contents

GENEVA — The Geneva Council of State released a proposal Wednesday to strengthen protections for people with disabilities, the canton's first formal rights initiative in this area, according to a statement issued from the Council's offices on the Rue de l'Hôtel-de-Ville. The proposal's central feature, officials said, is that it will strengthen rights. Which rights remain under review. Asked to identify at least one right the framework would protect, the Council's Office for Inclusive Legislative Process referred this publication to its forthcoming second phase, the timing of which has not been announced. Rights was used throughout the statement; specific appeared nowhere in it.

Quotation

We have begun the important work of identifying which improvements are improvements. Until that identification is complete, we are not in a position to say what the improvements will be, and we would ask that residents not speculate.”

Caroline Brisset-Ndiaye
rights framework
  • draft proposal (strengthen disability rights)
  • list of rights to strengthen
    not yet — second phase
  • define 'strengthen'
  • timeline for specifics
  • ask sector groups what they'd want
  • confirm the rights exist first
  • budget line (see fiscal memo)
  • announce framework (done Wed)
  • find out which rights are rights
  • next meeting — agenda TBD
CoS
Council of State, Canton de Genève
Rigor in every direction
:
Municipal Finance Coordinators
:
Office for Inclusive Legislative Process
:
Wednesday
:
Cost Reduction Targets and Rights Framework Alignment
Cost Reduction Targets:
  • •Municipalities are asked to identify 6% reductions in discretionary social program spending by the close of the fiscal cycle.
  • •Rights framework announcements are considered non-discretionary and do not offset cost reduction targets.
Terminology:
  • •'Strengthen': to be defined in a subsequent phase.
  • •'Protections': a general category of commitments not yet listed.
  • •'Framework': a structure whose contents are under review.
  • •'Commitment': the Council's intention to later decide what it is committed to.

Please route all disability-related inquiries to the Office for Inclusive Legislative Process, which will respond upon completion of the identification phase.

With continued rigor,
Maël Ferrand-Oberson, Senior Coordinator, Legislative Sequencing
Officials at a podium in a fluorescent-lit government room, with a blank banner, while one holds up an empty folding chair.

Officials present the framework's first and only completed element.

Framework Remains Under Review

Disability advocates in Geneva, reached by phone, said they had been told the framework would clarify which rights it protects. Several said they had not yet received a list. The Council's spokesperson said the identification phase was proceeding and that residents could expect specifics once it concluded. No conclusion date was offered. The announcement arrived the same week municipalities were asked to find cuts to discretionary social spending, a request the Council did not connect to the rights framework.

Next Steps

Once rights are identified, a further phase will determine which identified rights are strengthenable. The Council has not said when that phase will begin. A rights framework with undefined rights is, for now, a procedural skeleton.

More from Geneva