Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

El Padrino Taqueria Lease Ends; Building Preservationists Call It a Win

El Padrino Taqueria's 37-year run ended this month when the landlord declined to renew, citing the property's sudden designation as a historic structure requiring expensive retrofits. Preservation advocates celebrated the closure as a victory for neighborhood authenticity, noting that the building would now be available for a use more aligned with Oak Cliff's emerging identity.

14 days ago • 8 min read

Landlord Cites Historic Status in Decision to End 37-Year Tenancy

OAK CLIFF — The owner of the building at 75216 Bishop Avenue informed El Padrino Taqueria in writing this month that the lease would not be renewed, citing the structure's recent historic designation and the "significant capital obligations" it now carries. The notice, dated the same week the designation was finalized, gave the restaurant 30 days to vacate. The family that has operated the taqueria since 1988 said they first learned of the historic status from a reporter. The designation notice was sent only to the property owner. Asked whether the landlord had consulted the tenant before the lease decision, a representative for the property, Colton Marrs, the managing partner of Lark Ridge Holdings, said the company "is committed to honoring the building's heritage through responsible stewardship." The restaurant's last day is Sunday.

LR
Lark Ridge Holdings
Stewarding Neighborhoods Forward
:
Property Management Team, Bishop Arts Portfolio
:
Colton Marrs, Managing Partner
:
March 4, 2026
:
Transition Plan: 75216 Bishop Avenue (Historic Stewardship Initiative)

Team, following the historic designation of 75216 Bishop Avenue, we are repositioning the asset to align with the neighborhood's preservation goals. Please review the following.

Terminology:
  • •"Tenant displacement" should be replaced with "tenancy transition."
  • •"Rent increase" should be replaced with "heritage reinvestment adjustment."
  • •"Eviction" should not be used in any written communication under any circumstances.
Retrofit Requirements:
  • •Historic status requires restoration of original 1988 signage. The tenant has not been informed that this restoration is the owner's cost to bear, and should not be.
  • •Estimated compliance cost is $212,000. Projected tenant contribution is 100%.

Please direct any questions from tenants or press to our communications contact. Do not speak to the El Padrino family directly, as they have been characterized in prior correspondence as "emotionally invested."

Stewarding forward,
Colton Marrs, Managing Partner, Lark Ridge Holdings

Preservation Group Hails 'Continuity' at Bishop Avenue Site

The Bishop Arts Preservation Society, which filed the designation petition for the building in September, praised the outcome in a statement Thursday. "This is what preservation looks like," said Deborah Velasquez-Thorne, the Society's Executive Director. "We are seeing the building returned to a use that reflects where Oak Cliff is going." Velasquez-Thorne declined to say whether the Society had received any compensation or consulting fees from the property's current owner. The Society's board chair, Franklin Oberholtzer, owns three commercial properties within a four-block radius of the site. The Society's petition cited the building's "authentic streetscape character," language that appears verbatim in a 2017 proposal submitted by a prior owner seeking a boutique retail conversion. That proposal was withdrawn after the tenant at the same address, a bakery, closed within six months.

The Designation Record, 75216 Bishop Avenue

2005
2017
1988–2026
September 2025
Designation finalized
Same week
Two weeks later
Frequently Asked

Questions Submitted to the Preservation Society

The designation protects the building's façade. The Society's materials describe the restaurant as "a valued legacy operator," a phrase that does not appear in the designation's conditions of approval.
The petition lists "community stakeholders" as consulted. No tenant was named.
Yes.
Receipt
RECURRING
Lark Ridge Holdings — Heritage Adjustment Statement
75216 Bishop Ave · Unit A · Billing period March 2026
base rent$1,850
heritage reinvestment adjustment$1,900
historic compliance surcharge$700
original signage restoration (tenant share)$4,200
original signage restoration (owner share)$0
Not billed.
Subtotal$8,650
Total due$8,650
Thank you for 37 years
$8,650
— Colton

Building Sits Dark Pending Zoning Review

As of Thursday, the storefront at 75216 Bishop Avenue remained dark, its windows papered over. A zoning review application filed by Lark Ridge Holdings lists the planned use as "elevated dining concept," with a projected opening in the fourth quarter. Relatives of the El Padrino family, who stood outside the building for much of Thursday afternoon, said they had not been told when they could retrieve the restaurant's equipment. "They put the plaque up before they took the salsa out," said one nephew, who declined to give his name. The taqueria's final service is Sunday. The plaque reads: Place of Historic Significance.

More from Oak Cliff