Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Crown Cork & Seal Developer Demands Tax Incentives for Maintaining Abandoned Industrial Wasteland

Real estate speculators seeking tax incentives for the historic Crown Cork & Seal industrial site in East Baltimore argued Thursday that leaving 42 acres of rusted corrugated iron untouched since 1982 provides an essential urban aesthetic service. The developer's prospectus notes that maintaining zero employment protects the property from wear and tear.

1 month ago • 8 min read

Developer Asks City to Pay for a Site Nobody Has Entered

Industrial Holdings LLC asked city officials Thursday for a package of tax incentives for the former Crown Cork & Seal site in East Baltimore, arguing that leaving 42 acres of rusted corrugated iron untouched since 1982 is itself a public good. The application describes the property as an urban aesthetic asset. The developer's application asks the city to pay for the absence of work at the site. Lorne Vantreese, managing partner of Industrial Holdings, said the company is not asking the city to clean anything up. “We are asking the city to recognize that nobody has touched it,” Vantreese said in an interview at the firm's office on an upper floor of a Charles Street tower. “Most buildings are disturbed every year. This one has been left alone for more than forty years. That is a rare thing to preserve.”

Proposed Preservation Credit for Unused Property

  • +The prospectus lists zero employees as the property's central asset.
  • +Preservation credits would be calculated on the building's unchanged condition.
  • +Nothing on the site has changed since the plant closed, and the developer considers that the argument.

  • −The application identifies four distinct types of asbestos on site and does not propose removing any.
  • −A historic designation normally follows a building's history, not its absence of history.
  • −The incentive would reward the owner for a condition the city has not documented since 1982.

The Argument for Doing Nothing

The prospectus argues that the site's value lies in what has not happened there. It cites zero employees since 1982 as evidence of “sustained environmental stillness,” and asks the city to credit the company for each year the plant stays dark. A two-page appendix titled “Community Benefit” lists the corrugated iron, the weeds growing through the rail spur, and a loading dock that has never been asked to do anything. Vantreese said the neighborhood has been a good neighbor to the property. “We have received no complaints from the site,” he said. Asked whether the company had considered demolition, Vantreese declined to comment on demolition, on the cleanup of the asbestos, on the closing, or on the word “ruin,” which he said he would not use. He then used it.

Company's Earlier Filing Describes Harbor Sheen as an Asset

Industrial Holdings' last comparable filing, for a shuttered warehouse on the Canton waterfront, described an oil sheen on the harbor as “a reflective feature the neighborhood has come to expect.” The filing is still listed as pending. The company has used the category historic character for both properties, and both applications cite the condition of the site as the reason for the request. The company has now asked for incentives on two properties it describes as improved by their damage.

Application Pending

The filing from Industrial Holdings LLC runs four pages, three of which are photographs of the fence. The application describes 1982 as the property's most valuable year. The incentives are pending City Council review.

More from Baltimore Metro