Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

City Says It Can't Afford Raises, Then Asks Strikers to Fund the Strike Hotline

The City of Portland said Friday that its budget cannot absorb a wage increase for roughly 800 striking workers, adding that a $12,000 line item for a new budget-optics consultant was "essential to restraint." Union representatives said the consultant's first deliverable was a slide deck titled "Why Your Number Is Not Your Value."

7 days ago • 8 min read

City Declines Raises, Retains Consultant to Make Declining Look Better

PORTLAND — The City of Portland said Monday that the strike of roughly 800 municipal workers has entered its ninth day, and that the city's budget office has spent the first eight of them reviewing a $12,000 consultant contract retained to advise on what the city's budget looks like when it is not raising wages. A spokesperson for the budget office, Dana Hollister, said the firm's work product, a 91-page slide deck, would be presented to the bargaining table as evidence of restraint. Asked whether the deck addresses the union's demand for a cost-of-living adjustment, Hollister said it addresses "the feeling of cost-of-living adjustments." Union representatives said they received the deck through a public records request and that its opening slide is titled "Why Your Number Is Not Your Value." The city has paid a consulting firm to tell striking workers their wages are a perception problem.

PC
City of Portland, Office of Budget Optics
Restraint Is a Story We Tell Together
:
All Bargaining Unit Stakeholders
:
Gwendolyn Ashfield-Duque, Senior Advisor, Fiscal Perception Strategy (contracted)
:
Thursday, Day Six of Strike Action
:
Reframing the Wage Conversation Around Shared Restraint

This memo summarizes the firm's recommended approach to the upcoming listening session, which the city has committed to holding in the same room where the negotiating table was previously located.

Terminology Adjustments:
  • •Replace "wage increase" with "compensation evolution."
  • •Replace "strike" with "a period of collective pause."
  • •Replace "workers" with "valued participants in the restraint journey."
  • •Replace "we cannot afford it" with "we are choosing not to currently prioritize it."

Our analysis indicates that the phrase "we cannot afford it" generates the strongest negative sentiment in the city's own staff survey. The recommended replacement is expected to reduce perceived hostility without changing the underlying number.

Projected Outcomes:
  • •Strike hotline staffing costs remain outside the scope of this engagement.
  • •Consultant invoice remains unpaid pending the city's own restraint review.
  • •Measured silence is projected to outperform any public response.
With restraint,
Gwendolyn Ashfield-Duque, Senior Advisor, Fiscal Perception Strategy
Receipt
PENDING
Strike Hotline Operating Costs
Portland Metro · Days 1–9 · Billed to Striking Workers' Association
call routing, 24-hour$1,840.00
interpreter line, 6 languages$2,310.00
volunteer coordinator, hourly$1,260.00
picket schedule text blasts$412.60
recorded city-policy announcements$0.00
Provided by the city at no charge.
projected restraint savings$0.00
consultant invoice, unpaid$12,000.00
Amount Due, Association$5,822.60
for the consultant
$5,822.60
— the hotline is saving the city money too
A city worker in a high-visibility vest stands on an empty sidewalk beside a painted picket marker, holding a clipboard, with two folding chairs facing a lone podium.

Designated listening session location, Day Six. Attendance is voluntary.

Quotation

We just want to be clear that a listening session is not a negotiation. It is a room in which we are listening, and the workers are in it.”

Quote as delivered by a city spokesperson; the speaker is an invented character.
Dana Hollister
Budget office briefing, Portland City Hall, Day Eight of strike action
The listening session has been scheduled in the same room as the failed negotiation, and the spokesperson distinguishes the two by describing only where the listening happens.

Union Steward Declines to Attend Listening Session

A union steward, who asked not to be named while the strike remains active, said the membership had voted to decline the invitation to the listening session on the grounds that the room was already known to them. "We have been in that room," the steward said. "They gave us the chairs, and then they told us the chairs were the offer." The city confirmed the session will proceed at 9 a.m. Friday without union representation, and that the consultant's deck will be presented as the agenda. The city's answer to eight days of wage demands is a presentation about how the wage demands look.

More from Portland Metro