Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

City Extends Oak Cliff Viaduct Study; Uncertain Timeline Described as Commitment to Excellence

Dallas officials announced an eighteen-month extension to the Jefferson and Hampton viaducts feasibility study, citing the need for comprehensive analysis of replacement, repair, and retention scenarios. The delay, which postpones any decision until 2027, was praised by civic leaders as evidence of the city's dedication to getting the infrastructure question right.

14 days ago • 8 min read

DALLAS — The City of Dallas announced Thursday that its study of the aging Jefferson and Hampton viaducts will run through 2027 and, the city's transportation office said, may run through 2029 if the consultants' current scope is treated as a starting point. Officials described the eighteen-month extension as a "comprehensive commitment" to the question of whether the viaducts should be replaced, repaired, or retained. Asked how the question would be answered, Transportation Director Paul Hendrickson said the study would answer it "at the appropriate time, in the appropriate depth, by the appropriate consultant." The viaducts were built in the 1930s and 1940s, decades past their stated design lives. The city's previous studies, conducted in 2008, 2015, and 2021, each concluded that more study was needed. The current study has now been extended past the date the 2021 study recommended for a decision.

DOT
Dallas Department of Transportation — Infrastructure Deliberation Office
Deliberately Considering Since 2008
:
Viaduct Study Steering Committee; Stakeholder Engagement Subcommittee
:
Marisol Quintanar-Weeks, Deputy Director of Deliberative Momentum
:
October 2, 2024
:
Revised Decision Timeline and Terminology Alignment

Following the preliminary findings, which were inconclusive, the committee has determined that additional data is required to ensure no conclusion is reached prematurely.

Terminology Alignment:
  • •"Decision" is now to be read as "a future event that may occur".
  • •"Delay" is now to be read as "thoughtful sequencing".
  • •"Failure" is now to be read as "a learning opportunity for the next consultant".

The stakeholder input phase has been added. Stakeholders will provide input on the findings of the previous study, which the committee has discarded, to be followed by a new consultant, which the committee has also hired, to produce a new study with findings that will likely be inconclusive.

Reaffirmed Commitments:
  • •The viaducts remain in service.
  • •The 2027 timeline remains under review.
  • •No neighborhood has been asked to wait longer than necessary for a decision that has not yet been scheduled.
With continued deliberation,
Marisol Quintanar-Weeks, Deputy Director of Deliberative Momentum

Four Studies, Zero Decisions

🛣️1938
Jefferson Viaduct opens
Built to carry traffic for an estimated service life that has long since expired.
📋2008
First viaduct study
Concludes that more study is needed.
📋2015
Second viaduct study
Concludes that more study is needed, with additional data requirements identified.
📋2021
Third viaduct study
Concludes that more study is needed. A decision is recommended by 2025.
⏳October 2024
Current study extended
Eighteen-month extension to 2027 announced. Study budget increased 40% the previous month with no change in stated deliverables.
❔2027
Decision date (under review)
Officials confirm the date is subject to revision and will be communicated when it is known.
Oct 3
viaduct stuff
  • call consultant re: scope (they said 'wait for the stakeholder phase')
  • ask if the new firm has ever seen an oak cliff street
    they're from houston
  • reconcile 2021 findings vs 2024 findings vs 2026 findings (are they the same doc?)
  • get budget for 'stakeholder listening sessions' — 40% up, deliverable unchanged
  • tell board member about the commercial real estate thing (again)
  • book the 2027 meeting (2029?)
  • look up what 'phase 4 of 7' means
  • ribbon for kickoff — who ordered the scissors
  • the big ones
  • ask residents what they think (they've said it three times)
  • decide what 'decide' means

A Study Where the Process Is the Product

The study's consultant, a Houston firm with no prior Oak Cliff projects, did not respond to a request for comment. A spokesperson for the firm said by email that the firm "is committed to delivering a thorough, data-informed process that respects the community's time." Oak Cliff residents who drive the two viaducts daily say the traffic patterns have not changed in the past decade. A commercial property owner who sits on the study's community board, and who also serves on a commercial real estate board that has advocated for demolition, said the study was "proceeding exactly as designed." A spokesperson for the city said the study budget increase reflects "expanded engagement," which has taken the form of meetings. Meetings about the study now outnumber its deliverables. The viaducts, which were built to last a few decades, have been the subject of a study for about as long as they were in service.

More from Oak Cliff