Poisonal
Pass it along a thing worth keeping

Baltimore vs Detroit Debate Escalates After Residents Realize Comparison Itself Is the Insult

A long-running online argument over which city "should" be visited reached a turning point Thursday when participants on both sides recognized that being compared to each other was the actual slight, regardless of outcome. "We're not even in the same region," said Baltimore resident Dana Kowalski, noting the debate's existence implies both cities require a justification case before tourists will consider them.

15 days ago • 8 min read

Debate Stalls as Both Sides Recognize the Premise Is the Problem

DETROIT — A travel comparison debate between Baltimore and Detroit that has run continuously on online forums since 2019 reached an unexpected conclusion Thursday, when participants on both sides arrived at the same realization simultaneously: being weighed against each other was the insult all along. "We were arguing about which one of us deserves a weekend," said Dana Kowalski, a Baltimore resident in her thirties, who posted the realization at 11:40 p.m. "Then it hit me. Neither of us was asked if we wanted to be a finalist." A Detroit resident, who asked not to be identified and declined to be sorted into a comparison, agreed within the hour. Both threads were locked by moderators, who said they had no category for the complaint. The debate had never once asked whether either city was interested in competing.

🦀
🏭
🌊

Both Sides of the Argument 🧠

3 ·
🦀
Dana Kowalski
11:02 PM
Okay so I think we've been doing this wrong. Who said we were a list?
🏭
Marcus Holloway
11:04 PM
Dana I've been on the Detroit side of this for six years and I'm going to be honest, I didn't know there was a second side until about ten minutes ago.
🌊
Priya Venkataraman
11:05 PM
My cousin in Baltimore sent me the link to the Which Should You Visit article and I didn't even read past the headline. The headline was enough.
😩14
Marcus Holloway has changed the chat name to Neither of Us Asked
🦀
Dana Kowalski
11:08 PM
Thank you. Nobody ever writes 'Chicago vs Nashville' and then asks Nashville how it feels about being a referendum.
💯31
🏭
Marcus Holloway
11:09 PM
Nashville is not even in the same region as us and nobody has ever once framed it as the alternative to anything.
🌊
Priya Venkataraman
11:11 PM
That's the thing though. Neither city is being compared to a thriving city. We're always the other option, the cheaper option, the one you have to justify.
😔22
🦀
Dana Kowalski
11:12 PM
I'm not justifying Baltimore to a travel blog. I'm not doing a pros-and-cons table for my own hometown.
🏭
Marcus Holloway
11:14 PM
Same. I'm not making a case for the Renaissance Center to someone who has already decided it's a Buffalo.
🌊
Priya Venkataraman
11:15 PM
Okay but who started the poll, though
Priya Venkataraman has left the chat
🦀
Dana Kowalski
11:16 PM
She has been a Buffalo person the whole time.
Marcus Holloway
Quotation

We were arguing about which one of us deserves a weekend.”

Dana Kowalski
Baltimore resident, posted to an online travel forum
The debate's framing treats tourism as a verdict rather than an invitation, which is the insult the two residents identified.
Venn Diagram

Which City Gets the Question First

Baltimore5 itemsDetroit5 items1shared
BALTIMORE
4
  • Chesapeake Bay
  • Harbor waterfront
  • Harvey-era rowhouses
  • Inner Harbor pitch deck
IN COMMON
1
  • Tourism budget for explaining itself
DETROIT
4
  • Great Lakes shoreline
  • Riverfront redevelopment
  • Comeback city narrative
  • Nashville comparisons
Excerpt from the Last Comparison Forum Thread
Online travel forum, Thursday, 11:20 p.m. | Archived by the forum's moderation team
MODERATOR:
Locking this thread for review. Please direct further comparisons to the Which Should You Visit subforum.
BALTIMORE POSTER:
[long pause] There is no subforum for not being compared. We checked. There is one for Buffalo versus Cleveland but it was cancelled.
MODERATOR:
That is not in the scope of the forum.
DETROIT POSTER:
Then we are scoping it now. Neither of us asked to be the other option.

The Buffalo and Cleveland Debate Was Scheduled, Then Cancelled

A similar forum debate between Buffalo and Cleveland was scheduled for the same week but cancelled after neither city's residents agreed to participate. A Cleveland spokesperson, Teodora Brandvold, said the decision reflected a shared sense that the question was not the point. "We would like to be asked nothing," Brandvold said in a statement issued from the city's tourism bureau. Both cities have since redirected their travel-marketing budgets toward producing a single document explaining why the question is insulting. Neither city has yet agreed to receive the document.

More from Hampden